Milestone 0 · scenario replay · seed 20260807

First Light

Something in the belt began converting asteroid material into more of itself. Over eleven days a picket watched it, a directorate authorised a strike on information half an hour stale, and a two-kilometre beam array put 131 megawatts onto its radiator. Nobody involved can tell you whether it worked.

decision age
27 min
how old the picture was when the order went out
track before / after
1,124×
56 km fused, 50 m once the interceptor closed
radiator
748 K
against a 720 K limit
P(mission kill)
0.77
believed. truth: kill

The engagement

Two positions, and the distance between them

The amber marker is where the seed actually is. The cyan marker is where the Heliocentric Commonwealth believes it is, with the disc showing how wrong that belief could be. The Commonwealth never sees the amber marker. Neither does its beam.

Inner system, ecliptic plane

objective truth Commonwealth belief orbits
day 0.0

Eleven days of watching, six of closing, and one shot.

Finding one

Every fact arrives already old

Each observation travels twice: photons from the seed to the picket, then a report from the picket to Earth. Amber is the light in flight; cyan is the report in relay. By the time anything reaches a decision-maker it describes a world roughly half an hour gone.

event happensage on arrivallook 128mlook 228mlook 328mlook 428mlook 528mlook 628mlook 727mlook 827m
lookrange AUSNR light minrelay minage on arrival
10.90487.520.828
20.90477.420.728
30.89467.420.628
40.89457.420.428
50.88447.320.328
60.88437.320.228
70.87427.320.127
80.87417.220.027

Finding one and a half

The rule of engagement refuses seven times

Authority is not a switch. The directorate reviews its policy every time the picture changes — 8 times in eleven days — and declines 7 of them, because release requires eight independent looks and not one confident classification. A rule that fires on a single good look is exactly what a decoy is for.

dayreviewwhy
0.02withheldclass confidence 0.72 below required 0.80
1.52withheldtrack rests on 2 observation(s); 8 independent looks required before release
3.02withheldtrack rests on 3 observation(s); 8 independent looks required before release
4.52withheldtrack rests on 4 observation(s); 8 independent looks required before release
6.02withheldtrack rests on 5 observation(s); 8 independent looks required before release
7.52withheldtrack rests on 6 observation(s); 8 independent looks required before release
9.02withheldtrack rests on 7 observation(s); 8 independent looks required before release
10.52releasedpolicy pol.scd.0001 permits beam_engagement; track trk.belt.0001 meets every confidence predicate

Finding two

You cannot shoot what you have only roughly located

Eight looks pulled the track from 164 km of uncertainty down to 56 km. That is a real improvement and it is three orders of magnitude short of what the shot needs. Uncertainty enters the beam's spot budget directly, so a vague estimate is not merely a riskier shot — it is a physically weaker one, spread across every place the target might have been.

100 km10 km1 km100 m10 m beam spot 300 m — uncertainty must fall below this terminal designation — 50 m day 0 day 17 position uncertainty (1σ)

This is why the interceptor exists. Terminal designation is not a refinement of the engagement; it is the precondition for one.

Finding three

Damage is thermal, and nothing has hit points

The beam does not breach anything. It adds 131 MW to a machine already shedding 125 MW, and asks its radiator to find a new equilibrium. The radiator cannot. It fails, and the seed throttles to whatever the surviving panel can carry.

heat load 125 MW its own +131 MW from the beam radiator everything right of this line has nowhere to go — capacity at the 720 K limit is 219 MW equilibrium temperature the combined load demands 748 K against a 720 K limit. the radiator fails; the seed throttles to what remains

Finding four · the one that decides whether this is a game

A wounded machine and a hiding one look the same

Two days later the picket looks again and measures 18 MW where there had been 125. Something changed. But a half-sized radiator running hot and a full-sized one running cool are the same measurement — flux cannot separate area from temperature. The seed may be crippled. It may simply have noticed the beam and stopped advertising.

radiator destroyed chose to go quiet what the picket measured — 18 MW 0 35 MW 70 MW emitted power the observation is consistent with

Posterior: 0.77 that the strike achieved a mission kill

Run again with the strike scripted to fail, and the posterior lands at 0.54 — still uncertain, in the other direction. Both sit inside the (0.15, 0.85) band the milestone requires, which was written to be able to fail.

That test is the whole reason to build M0 before anything else. If battle damage assessment had come out legible, the fog would have been decorative and the design premise false. It did not, and the ambiguity is structural rather than tuned: it survives because of what a radiometer physically cannot measure.

What the machine guarantees

Constraints held, not asserted

Conservation

Energy residual exactly zero

Beam emission reappears precisely as absorbed plus missed. Of 6.6 GW leaving the array, 131 MW reached the target and the rest lit empty space. Waste is accounted, not ignored.

Determinism

Same seed, same run, down to the event identifiers

Event identity is a hash of causal position rather than a counter, so a counterfactual that changes one branch leaves every unrelated event untouched and a replay diff points at a cause instead of a symptom.

Search

One all-sky survey costs 1.6 years

The sky is 8.4 trillion diffraction-limited pixels wide. A processing seed is detectable to tens of AU, so sensitivity was never the constraint. Where you point is.

Authority

The agent could not consult the truth

It received a frozen view holding tracks, arrived messages, and last-reported own-unit status — with no reference that leads back to world state. The firewall is structural; there is nothing to police.